Was Hardik Pandya-Mumbai Indians Trade Illegal?

Was Hardik Pandya
Was Hardik Pandya

Was Hardik Pandya-Mumbai Indians Trade Illegal?

Colonel Arvinder Singh, the Chief Operating Officer (COO) of the Gujarat Titans, has revealed something shocking about Mohammed Shami.

The Gujarat Titans franchise signed the Indian speedster before the 2022 Indian Premier League, and he recently signed on as one of their retained players for the 2024 Indian Premier League. Because of his relentless pursuit of wickets during the IPL 2023, Shami was awarded the “Purple Cap” earlier this year. Considering that he concluded India’s World Cup 2023 campaign as the competition’s leading wicket-taker, his bowling stocks increased even more ahead of the IPL 2024 auctions.

Gujarat Titans COO charges unfair trade practices by franchises

Mohammed Shami, an Indian fast bowler, was commended by Gujarat Titans COO Arvinder Singh for his outstanding run with the ball off late. He praised the speedster for his IPL 2023 “Purple Cap” run and his brilliant performance for Team India in the 2023 World Cup.

The reason for Singh’s significance in the Gujarat Titans camp is because he claimed other IPL teams used dirty play to get the speedster away from them. He hinted that certain teams are approaching Shami directly for a potential deal, which is against BCCI policy, in a recent interview with News18. He declared:

“It is the right of any organization to add talented players to strengthen their roster. Mohammed Shami has performed admirably for us; he was the Purple Cap Holder the previous season and had good results in the World Cup. He is a vital member of our group. It is improper for certain franchises to approach players personally. The BCCI has created a trading protocol. An expression of interest is submitted to the BCCI, which then shares it with the relevant franchise, allowing them to decide whether or not to proceed with the transfer.

The trade deals and player retention ahead of the IPL auctions always create a buzz in the cricketing world. One such trade that caught everyone’s attention was the transfer of Hardik Pandya from the Gujarat Titans to the Mumbai Indians. However, recent revelations by Gujarat Titans Chief Operating Officer (COO), Colonel Arvinder Singh, have raised questions about the legality of this trade. Singh alleged that certain franchises had directly approached their star pacer, Mohammed Shami, without following the proper procedures set by the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI). In this article, we will delve into the details of the trade and explore whether it was indeed illegal, as claimed by the Gujarat Titans COO.

Mohammed Shami’s Stellar Performances

Mohammed Shami’s prowess with the ball has been evident in recent times. During IPL 2023, he emerged as the highest wicket-taker, earning him the prestigious Purple Cap. His excellent form continued in the ICC World Cup 2023, where he played a pivotal role in India’s journey to the final. Shami’s consistent performances across formats have transformed him from being considered a one-format bowler to a key player in the Indian cricket team.

Allegations of Unfair Trade

Colonel Arvinder Singh, the COO of the Gujarat Titans, expressed his discontent with the approach made by certain IPL franchises to Mohammed Shami. In an interview with News18, Singh highlighted the importance of following the BCCI’s trading procedures. He stated that while every team has the right to strengthen their squad, directly approaching players without adhering to the established rules is unfair. Singh emphasized that the BCCI has put in place a procedure for trading, which involves expressing interest to the board and subsequently sharing the details with the concerned franchise. However, he did not disclose the name of the franchise that allegedly approached Shami without going through the proper channels.

Shami’s Importance to Gujarat Titans

Singh underlined Mohammed Shami’s significance to the Gujarat Titans franchise. He applauded Shami’s performances and highlighted that the pacer’s contributions were instrumental in their success, both in the IPL and the World Cup. Singh’s remarks reiterated the value of Shami as a key player for the Gujarat Titans and expressed his disappointment with the unfair approach by certain franchises.

Shami’s Current Status and Injury

Currently, Mohammed Shami is recuperating from an ankle injury. He recently visited Mumbai to consult with doctors and is expected to complete his recovery at the National Cricket Academy (NCA) in Bengaluru. Due to his injury, Shami has been rested from the white-ball series and will focus on his rehabilitation. However, he has been named in India’s test squad for the upcoming tour of South Africa, reaffirming his importance to the national team.

The Impact of the Allegations

The allegations made by Colonel Arvinder Singh have raised eyebrows and sparked discussions about the transparency and fairness of the trading process in the IPL. If the claims are proven true, it raises questions about the integrity of certain franchises and their disregard for the established rules. The BCCI may need to address these concerns and take appropriate action to ensure a level playing field for all teams.


The trade of Hardik Pandya from the Gujarat Titans to the Mumbai Indians has come under scrutiny due to allegations made by the Gujarat Titans COO, Colonel Arvinder Singh. The claims of unfair trade practices involving the direct approach to Mohammed Shami by certain franchises without following the BCCI’s procedures have raised concerns about the legality and transparency of the trade. The impact of these allegations on the IPL and the actions that the BCCI will take in response remain to be seen. As cricket fans, we hope for a fair and just trading system that upholds the integrity of the game.

Author: Deltin7News
Catch up with the latest and breaking Cricket News, detailed analysis on trending cricket topics, series and match previews, reviews, player interviews. We’re building a cricket product for the generation of always connected internet users and we need your talent and passion.